Research Brief:
Exposure/Effects-based Testing for Confined Disposal Facilities


Issue     

  


Contaminants in dredged material in Confined Disposal Facilities (CDFs) can move from substrates into food webs because of their contact with CDF-colonizing or CDF-inhabiting plants and animals, and as such can cause unacceptable risks outside the CDF. The Corps/EPA Technical Framework requires exposure-based effects assessments prior to dredging to evaluate impacts on plants and animals in cases where terrestrial placement is selected as a disposal alternative. Presently, no specific guidelines for contaminant residues in plants and animals exist. Moreover, risk assessment is based on exposure-based effects tests performed on index species, which may not necessarily give an accurate indication of the fate and effects of the contaminants in the species actually colonizing or inhabiting the CDF. The latter situation gives rise to uncertainty in relating the results of the index-species-based tests to ecosystems developing in CDFs. This uncertainty should be diminished, and guidance should be developed to standardize the interpretation of test results in risk assessment aimed at determining effective long-term management strategies for CDFs. Guidance is also required to evaluate other beneficial uses for contaminated dredged material in terrestrial areas.


Research/Objectives    

  


An objective of this research is to evaluate exposure-based effects testing of contaminated soils/sediments of CDFs that will relate the existing Corps ERDC plant and earthworm bioassay procedures to key ecosystem components and processes as part of an overall risk assessment. This research is quantifying the modulation of bioavailability as a function of sediment characteristics. It is establishing quantitative relationships between sediment characteristics, concentrations of contaminant species in sediments, and rates of contaminant bioaccumulation in plants at various relevant growth stages, and in earthworms at steady-state. These quantitative relationships are being used to formulate models on contaminant bioavailablity, fates in food chains, and risk assessment. This research is focusing on upland areas of CDFs where (a) sites are selected to represent sediment series characterized by increasing concentrations of metals and organics, (b) vegetation cover and predominant plant species of these sites are characterized, and (c) sediment biota of these sites are characterized. This research is determining biota-to-sediment-accumulation factors of, respectively, metals and organics in plants and earthworms. Bench-scale work is being field-verified in cooperation with Corps Districts. The ERDC index plant and earthworm species are included in the tests. Interpretive guidance minimizing risks and cost-effective management strategies is being provided.



(Continued)


What's New | DOTS | DOER


U.S. Army Engineer Research and Development Center

November 2001
www.erdc.usace.army.mil
www.wes.army.mil/el/dots/doer


Results/Products     

  

Exposure-based effects evaluation and interpretive guidance are being developed for effective management of contaminants to minimize unacceptable risks in CDFs, and for beneficial soil/sediment use projects. Scenarios chosen indicate where management is required, and which strategies can be followed prior to dredging so that placement, site design, and remedial action can be cost effectively implemented. The research is taking advantage of the most recent developments in exposure-based effects testing procedures and is supplying data required for risk assessment at CDFs and for beneficial sediment/soil use projects. This research will be completed 30 September 2003.


Research Team    

  

E. P. H. Best
U.S. Army Engineer Research and Development Center
Waterways Experiment Station
3909 Halls Ferry Road, Vicksburg, Mississippi 39180-6199